Buffalo Bills star Josh Allen is no stranger to pulling off spectacular plays, but the quarterback’s greatness still has a tendency to stop people in amazement.

Case in point, on Sunday Night Football, when Allen connected with receiver Trent Sherfield for an improbable touchdown against the Dolphins that turned Miami coach Mike McDaniel into a meme for the ages.

With Buffalo on second-and-goal down 7–0, Allen fired a rocket of a pass off a Dolphins defensive lineman’s helmet, which hung in the air and fell into Sherfield’s waiting arms. To make the surreal play that much better, the wideout showed off some picture-perfect toe-drag, a sequence that stunned viewers and left McDaniel with a blank stare on his face in disbelief.

As if Sunday’s game wasn’t big enough, Allen and Sherfield’s electric play added even more to a Bills-Dolphins matchup with major playoff implications and the AFC’s No. 2 seed on the line. Allen’s TD pass also went down as quite a way for the QB to move closer to continuing his 11-game streak of tossing two or more scores against Miami.

With images of McDaniel’s reaction making the rounds online, here’s a look at a few of the best reactions: